Tuesday, February 13, 2018

THE ANALYSIS VALID OR RELIABLE OF THESIS: THE STUDENTS' ABILITY IN USING ANTONYM IN ENGLISH READING PASSAGE AT THE FIRST YEAR OF SMK


3.3.  Instrument of the Research
The instruments of the research were test in reading and questionnaire.
a.       Reading test passage
1.      Reading test passage consists of 10 items. The test is done with the aim to evaluate students’ achievement in learning antonym by using reading passage.
b.      Questionnaire
The second instrument used in this research is questionnaire. The questionnaire of this research consisted of some questions related to the difficulties in learning antonym in English.  Furthermore, in this questionnaire the writer used five alternatives choices in every question, as follows:
a.       Strongly agree
b.      Agree
c.       Uncertain
d.      Disagree
e.       Strongly disagree

The thesis is valid and reliable because At the outset, the researchers needed to consider the face validity of the questionnaire. Face validity can be described as a sense that the questionnaire looks like it measures what it was intended to measure. Were the questions phrased appropriately? Did the options for responding seem appropriate?
Content validity is also usually one of the first ways to ensure the validity of a questionnaire or other measure. The researchers could have asked experts in depression to consider their questions against the known symptoms of depression. These symptoms include depressed mood, sleeping problems, weight changes and physical pain. To have content validity, the questionnaire should include items about known symptoms.
The researchers could have also established criterion validity. How well do the results from their questionnaire compare with other measures of depression? One way to assess this is to give the workers two questionnaires: a “gold standard” questionnaire that's already been validated, and the new one. Then they could compare findings. Another way might be to follow the workers over time to see how the questionnaire results relate to the workers' actual treatment for depression later on.
Unlike physical traits such as weight or blood pressure, depression is not easily seen or measured. This is called a “construct.” The researchers might do some mini-experiments with their questionnaire and other measures to establish construct validity. For instance, if workers were given a questionnaire on a similar construct, such as psychological distress, the results should be related. A questionnaire on a different construct, such as happiness, would have opposite results.
 and Reliability refers to two things. First, reliability means the researchers would get similar results if they repeated their questionnaire soon afterwards with the same workers. The “repeatability” of the questionnaire would be high. This is called test-retest reliability.
The other aspect of reliability concerns the consistency among the questions. Because all the questions relate to depression, you would expect all the answers to be fairly consistent.
If our depression researchers were sloppy in ensuring the validity or reliability of their questionnaire, it could have affected their study's overall results. It's important to note that you can never prove reliability or validity conclusively, but results will be more accurate if the measures in a study are as reliable and valid as possible.
Based on the result of the data analysis and conclusion;
1.      The result of using antonym and finding score test and questionare of the student of SMK Kartika Palopo got means score 176.82, and the quesionaire gave of the result poor it means that the capability of the student was average
The biggest problem for the students in using antonym from the data show that many difficulties faced by the student in looking for antonym in text and not only they difficult in identifying antonym but the students also doing mistakes in writing the words, they didn’t know how to write the words.
Based on the mean score of the students namely 5.89, it is indicates that students ability in fair classification. By looking the students’ score classification, most of the students are in the poor classification (46.67%), 26.67% students are in fair classification, we can conclude that the students still have low ability in identifying antonym using in the text. 
2.      Some factors that hamper the students in using antonym :
a.       The student face the difficulties in finding ideas , for answering test  words, using antonym in english reading passage.
b.      The student seldom practice their reading skill to find antonym in reading passage
c.       The students still find difficulty in using antonym in reading passage

d.      the students also doing mistakes in writing  the words, they didn’t know how to find and using antonym in reading.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Simple Past Tense

But there are a lot of irregular past tense forms in English. Here are the most common irregular verbs in English, with their past tense fo...